Legal Thursday – Hoarders and Arbitration Questions

Don’t miss a single weekly post at No Sleep in Helena  at  Subscribe to the Facebook page as well and keep up with all the news of Helena, Alabama and the Shelby County area.

Welcome back to Lawyer Thursdays!  Last week went over so well, Hewy is going to allow me to continue to answer your legal questions each week! You can submit your legal question to any time.  You don’t have to have specific problem or issue.  I will be happy to answer those legal questions that you may have been wondering about for years!  Please put “Lawyer Thursdays” in the subject line as I also receive many emails through my website at www.  You may also call Davidson Law Firm at 685-4822 or come by the office located in Old Towne Helena.

Question: My next-door neighbor is a hoarder.  Does Helena have any restrictions for such activity?

Answer: That depends on what your neighbor is hoarding and where.  Helena does have an ordinance restricting junk, trash, and debris from your yard.  If the hoarding activity is inside the residence then the issue becomes more difficult and diverse.  Helena cannot do anything about what’s inside your residence (outside of illegal activity) unless it either becomes a public nuisance or a fire hazard.  For example, 28 dogs barking all hours of the day and night would be a public nuisance while hoarding of stacks of newspaper and magazines would be a fire hazard.  If the hoarding activity is creating a health hazard then your recourse is through the Shelby County Health Department.

Question:  Why is it that every time I want to buy something they make me sign a paper that says I can’t take them to court but instead I have to go a mediator?  Is this just a State of Alabama thing or does this occur in other states?

Answer:   I could write a whole book on this issue.  What you are referring to are arbitration agreements that exist nationwide and really started to encroach into our daily lives in the mid to late 1980’s.  Arbitration is legally binding mediation where the parties submit their arguments and evidence to a mutually agreed upon or Court appointed Arbitrator (who you have to pay in whole or in part) who will then decide the case.  There are no rights to appeal and there are no requirements that the Arbitrator even has to apply the law.

The Federal Arbitration Act was first passed by Congress in 1925 to encourage and allow businesses to agree to resolve disputes without the Court system.  However, as we all know, arbitration has now creeped into every aspect of consumer transactions and now employment agreements as well.  In essence, in exchange for the privilege of purchasing that car, house, motorcycle, boat, mobile home, mouse trap, or pack of gum you are also agreeing to the waiver of your rights under the Seventh Amendment of the United States Constitution which states,

“In suits at common law, where the value in controversy shall exceed twenty dollars, the right of trial by jury shall be preserved, and no fact tried by a jury, shall be otherwise re-examined in any Court of the United States, than according to the rules of the common law.”

The legislature of Alabama specifically prohibits arbitration. Ala. Code § 8-1-41(3) (1975).  However, the Federal Arbitration Act preempts our State law in almost every circumstance thanks to the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision expanding the scope of the Commerce Clause in Allied-Bruce Terminix Companies v. Dobson, 513 U.S. 265 (1995).  Under Dobson, there doesn’t seem to be any activity or transaction that does not affect interstate commerce bringing in the preemptive Federal laws.

Send your legal questions to Brian Davidson at

Please support Judge Furhmeister for re-election as Shelby County Probate Judge.

Fuhrmeister seeks another term as probate judge

Published 4:27pm Thursday, January 12, 2012


Shelby County’s current probate judge is looking for another go-round.

Jim Fuhrmeister announced Jan. 11 he is seeking the Republican nomination for probate judge in Shelby County. The primary election is March 13.

Jim Fuhrmeister

“I am proud of my accomplishments in the time I have served Shelby County, but there is much more to do,” Fuhrmeister said in a press release.

Fuhrmeister also serves as a special circuit judge, and he presides over the county’s mental health court.

He was honored with the National Alliance on Mental Illness 2011 Criminal Justice Award of the Year for his work with the mental health court.

Fuhrmeister also works with the Alabama Law Institute, serving on both the Real Estate Committee and the Collaborative Law Committee.

Probate judges across the state selected Fuhrmeister to serve on the Alabama Electronic Recording Commission, which drafts and implements standards and business practices to electronically record documents in Alabama’s probate offices.

Fuhrmeister, who is an Eagle Scout, serves on the boards of various Shelby County nonprofit organizations, such as Leadership Shelby County, Shelby Volunteers In Service, Harrison Regional Library and the J. Craig and Paige T. Smith Scholarship Foundation Inc.

He is also a member of the Shelby County Bar Association, the Alabama State Bar, the National College of Probate Judges and the Alabama Probate Judges Association.




Occupational Heart Disease for Firefighters

The Fight for Fire Fighter’s Workers’ Compensation benefits.

The following is the Alabama Court of Civil Appeals opinion regarding Jim Phillips’ workers’ compensation case for occupational heart disease arising from his employment as a firefighter for the City of Hoover.  Jim Phillips, a veteran firefighter, suffered from a heart attack that left him totally disabled.  I tried this case in Shelby County, Alabama and was able to both clarify and establish the law regarding occupational heart disease for  firefighters. Continue reading